Ringshank Nails vs. Screws for Roofing: Why Ringshank Nails Are Superior
When choosing fasteners for roofing, durability and performance are key. Two common fastener types often compared are ringshank nails vs screws for roofing. While screws are widely used in construction, ringshank nails offer distinct advantages, especially in dynamic environments like roofs that undergo daily temperature fluctuations. Let’s explore the science behind why ringshank nails outperform screws and why they’re the superior choice for long-lasting roofing installations.
Understanding Thermal Expansion and Fastener Loosening
Roofing materials expand and contract with daily and seasonal temperature changes. When the sun heats up a roof, the material expands, and when it cools down, it contracts. This constant expansion and contraction, also known as thermal movement, puts significant stress on the fasteners holding the roofing materials in place. In the case of screws for roofing, this stress can cause them to loosen over time.
Screws have continuous threads that bite into the material, creating small stress points. As temperatures fluctuate, these stress points weaken, especially where the threads meet the material. Over time, this can cause vibrational loosening, where the constant movement gradually causes screws to back out. This loosening leads to potential leaks, compromised structural integrity, and costly repairs.
Why Ringshank Nails Hold Firm
In contrast, ringshank nails offer a more resilient solution. Unlike screws, ringshank nails feature ridges along their shaft, which grip the material tightly as they are driven in. These ridges compress the surrounding fibers of the material, locking the nail into place and creating a mechanical bond that is highly resistant to movement.
The compression around the ridges of a ringshank nail means that even under the stress of thermal expansion, the nail stays firmly in place. This mechanical grip prevents the nail from slipping, even in environments with extreme temperature variations. As a result, ringshank nails for roofing provide a more secure and longer-lasting hold compared to screws.
Axial Load and Shear Forces: Ringshank Nails vs Screws
Roof fasteners experience two primary forces: axial load (the force pulling away from the roof, such as wind uplift) and shear forces (parallel movement, such as the weight of roofing materials). In comparing ringshank nails vs screws for roofing, nails provide superior resistance to both types of forces.
Ringshank nails distribute the load more evenly across the material due to their large surface area and mechanical grip. Screws, on the other hand, concentrate the load on the threads, which can create weak points under stress. As a result, screws are more likely to loosen or fail under axial or shear forces, especially after years of thermal expansion and contraction.
Metal Fatigue in Roofing: Ringshank Nails vs Screws
Another factor that affects the longevity of screws for roofing is metal fatigue. Over time, the constant expansion and contraction of the roof can cause the metal around the threads to weaken and fail. This leads to the gradual loosening of the screw, which can be exacerbated by temperature changes, wind, and other environmental factors.
These pictures demonstrate the common issue of screws loosening over time, especially in systems like PBR roofing. While our focus here is to highlight the problem with fasteners becoming undone, it’s important to recognize that this also reflects the inherent vulnerabilities in PBR-type systems. Over time, the reliance on exposed fasteners and screws in such systems can lead to compromised performance, particularly under thermal stress and environmental factors. This is why we advocate for more reliable, long-lasting solutions, like those offered by Spengler Industries.
In contrast, ringshank nails avoid the stress concentration found in screws. The ridges on the nail distribute the load more evenly across the material, reducing the risk of metal fatigue. This not only ensures that the fastener holds securely over time but also extends the lifespan of the roofing system as a whole.
Why Ringshank Nails Are the Superior Choice
- Thermal Resilience: Ringshank nails remain secure even under extreme temperature fluctuations. Their ridged design grips the material, preventing loosening due to thermal expansion.
- Superior Load Resistance: Ringshank nails are better equipped to handle both axial and shear forces. Their larger surface area contact and mechanical lock make them less likely to fail under stress compared to screws.
- Prevention of Metal Fatigue: The even distribution of stress along the ridges of a ringshank nail reduces the risk of metal fatigue, ensuring a longer lifespan for the fastener and the roof.
- Mechanical Grip: The rings along the shank of the nail create a tight mechanical lock that holds the material in place, even as it expands and contracts.
When it comes to choosing between ringshank nails vs screws for roofing, the choice is clear. Ringshank nails offer superior performance, better durability, and a longer lifespan, making them the ideal fastener for any roofing application.
Choosing the Right Size and Material for Ringshank Nails
For most metal roofing applications, 1-1/4″ ringshank nails are sufficient to secure your roofing material effectively. At Spengler Industries, we universally recommend using stainless steel ringshank nails across all our systems due to their superior resistance to corrosion and long-term durability. However, it’s crucial that the length of the nail extends at least 1/4″ longer than the total thickness of the substrate it penetrates to ensure a secure hold.
If you’re unsure about the right nail size or have any technical questions about your project, don’t hesitate to reach out to us. Our experts are ready to assist you in making the best choice for your roofing system.
Where to find 1-1/4 stainless steel ringshank nails:
We often recommend purchasing here.
Ready to make your roof last longer with the right fasteners? Contact Spengler Industries today to learn more about how ringshank nails can improve the durability and performance of your roofing system. Our team of experts is here to guide you toward the best solution for your next project. Don’t settle for less—choose fasteners that stand the test of time.
801-462-5264 Call now!
