Weathering of materials
We get asked about “tarnishing” quite a bit. There’s a big difference between weathering, patinating, and tarnishing.
When it comes to selecting materials for roofing and cladding, understanding how these metals react to environmental factors over time is crucial. Each metal has unique properties that influence its appearance and durability. Here, we explore the weathering characteristics of zinc, copper, stainless steel, terne (tin over stainless steel), brass, and titanium.
Weathering
Weathering refers to the natural process through which materials are altered or degraded due to exposure to atmospheric conditions over time. This can include physical, chemical, and biological factors such as sunlight, rain, wind, and pollution. Weathering affects all materials, including metals, and can result in changes in appearance, texture, and structural integrity. For metals, weathering typically involves oxidation and other chemical reactions that occur as the metal interacts with the environment.
Patination
Patination is a specific type of weathering process where a metal develops a protective surface layer, known as patina, due to oxidation and other chemical reactions. This process is most commonly associated with metals like copper, bronze, and zinc. The patina often manifests as a distinctive color change, such as the greenish-blue layer on copper or the matte gray on zinc. Unlike tarnish, patina is usually desirable because it not only enhances the aesthetic appeal of the metal but also acts as a protective barrier against further corrosion, thereby extending the metal’s lifespan.
Tarnishing
Tarnishing is the process through which a metal surface loses its luster and becomes dull or discolored due to a chemical reaction, often involving sulfur compounds in the air. Tarnish forms a thin layer of corrosion that typically appears on metals such as silver, brass, and copper. Unlike patina, tarnish is usually considered undesirable because it detracts from the metal’s appearance. Tarnish can often be removed through polishing, restoring the metal to its original shine.
Summary
- Weathering: The broad process of material alteration due to environmental exposure, affecting appearance and structure.
- Patination: A type of weathering where a protective, often aesthetically pleasing layer forms on metals like copper and zinc, enhancing durability.
- Tarnishing: The formation of a dull, discolored layer on metals like silver and brass due to chemical reactions, generally considered undesirable but removable through cleaning.
Understanding these processes helps in selecting the right materials for roofing and cladding, ensuring both durability and aesthetic longevity.
Zinc
Zinc is renowned for its long-lasting durability and self-healing properties. Over time, zinc develops a protective layer known as patina, which forms due to exposure to the elements. This patina starts as a bluish-gray hue and gradually softens to a matte gray. The patina not only gives zinc its distinctive aesthetic but also protects the metal from further corrosion, ensuring longevity, though zinc does thin over time due to its sacrificial nature. Unlike tarnish, which is typically considered undesirable, zinc’s patina is a sought-after feature that enhances its appearance and durability.
Copper
Copper is highly regarded for its aesthetic appeal and excellent weathering properties. When exposed to the environment, copper undergoes a natural oxidation process, developing a patina that changes from a shiny reddish-brown to various shades of green and blue over time. This patination process, which can take several years, acts as a protective barrier against corrosion. Cladding will patinate more slowly than roofs due to reduced exposure to rainfall and other elements. Unlike tarnish, copper’s patina is prized for its beauty and protective qualities.
Stainless Steel
Stainless steel is chosen for its sleek appearance and superior resistance to tarnish and corrosion. It owes its durability to a thin layer of chromium oxide that forms on its surface, preventing rust and maintaining its finish. In harsh coastal environments, a Duplex variety of stainless steel is recommended for enhanced resistance to chloride corrosion. Generally, stainless steel retains its appearance indefinitely, making it a popular choice for both modern and traditional architectural applications.
Terne (Tin over Stainless Steel)
Terne-coated stainless steel combines the strength of stainless steel with the traditional appearance of tin. The tin coating offers an initial matte gray finish that can weather slightly over time but does not undergo significant changes like patina or tarnish. The material goes up shiny from the mill, but softens to a matte finish shortly thereafter. The combination provides a durable and aesthetically pleasing option that requires minimal maintenance. The stainless steel substrate ensures longevity, while the tin coating offers a unique look that complements various architectural styles.
Brass
Brass, an alloy of copper and zinc, is known for its golden hue and resistance to corrosion. Over time, brass will develop a patina that can range from dark brown to green, depending on the environmental conditions. This patina serves as a protective layer, similar to copper. While tarnish on brass can occur, resulting in a duller appearance, it can often be polished away if a bright finish is desired. This is generally not the case in cartridge material for architectural applications. Many appreciate the aged look that patinated brass provides, as it adds character and depth to the material.
Titanium
Titanium is a premium metal known for its exceptional strength, light weight, and resistance to corrosion. Unlike other metals, titanium does not patinate or tarnish, maintaining its original appearance indefinitely. This makes it an ideal choice for environments with extreme conditions, including coastal areas and industrial zones. The primary consideration with titanium is its cost and longer lead times, as it is more expensive and less readily available than other roofing and cladding materials. However, its durability and maintenance-free nature often justify the investment for high-end projects.
Conclusion
When choosing materials for roofing and cladding, understanding the weathering properties of each metal is essential. Zinc, copper, stainless steel, terne, brass, and titanium each offer unique benefits and aesthetic qualities. Whether you prefer the evolving patina of copper and brass, the enduring finish of stainless steel and titanium, or the classic appearance of terne, each material provides a range of options to suit your architectural vision and environmental conditions.
At Spengler Industries, we pride ourselves on offering a variety of high-quality materials tailored to meet your specific needs. If you have further questions about our metal roofing and cladding solutions, please don’t hesitate to contact us.
Call today! 801-462-5264
