Yes, in most cases. Replacement metal shingles can be made to the size of the diamonds already on your roof, so the new work carries the same pattern as the old.
That matters more than it sounds. Old metal shingle roofs were made in sizes nobody stocks anymore, and a roof patched with the nearest thing from a catalog never looks right again. We make our diamond shingles to order, which means the roof sets the size and the shop follows.
Why the match matters
A diamond roof is a pattern, and the eye reads a pattern as a whole. Change the size of the diamond and three things go wrong at once:
- The scale shifts. Bigger diamonds make a roof look smaller and plainer. Smaller ones make it look busy.
- The lines stop meeting. Diamonds line up along ridges, valleys, dormers and eaves. A new size will not land where the old one did.
- The building loses its age. On an older house, the roof is a large part of what makes it look like itself.
If the building sits in a historic district, a review board may also expect new roofing to match the old in size and appearance. The National Park Service covers the reasoning in its guide to roofing for historic buildings.
What replacement metal shingles can match
Here is what we can match on our diamond metal shingles:
- Size. The diamond is made to the dimensions of your originals.
- Layout. The pattern is planned so the lines meet at ridges, valleys and edges the way they did before.
- Color. In most cases we can match a painted finish to the color you have, or the color the roof once was.
And here is what we will tell you plainly that we cannot:
- Pressed patterns. Many old shingles were stamped with ornament. Ours are smooth diamonds, so we match the shape and size, and the embossing is left to history.
- A hundred years of weather. New metal next to old metal looks new. A color match helps, and time does the rest.
Repair a section or replace the roof?
It depends on why the old shingles are failing.
If the damage is local, such as a fallen limb, one bad valley or a patch someone did poorly, new shingles made to match can restore that section and leave the rest alone.
If the roof is worn out everywhere, with rust coming through, loose fasteners and leaks in several places, a patch only buys a little time. In that case the better use of your money is a new roof in the original pattern, so the building keeps its look and gains a roof that will last.
Photos usually tell us which case you have.
How to measure for replacement metal shingles
You do not need to climb anything dangerous. From a safe spot, a ladder at the eave or an upstairs window, gather these:
- The visible diamond. Measure one diamond point to point, both across and up the slope.
- A run of several. Measure across five or ten diamonds in a row and note the count. This evens out small errors.
- Straight-on photos. Take a few with a tape measure lying in the picture.
- Wide photos. Show the whole roof, plus the ridges, valleys and edges.
- A loose shingle, if one has come off. Nothing beats the real thing in hand.
Send those to us through our contact page, along with where the building is. We will tell you whether a match is possible and what it would take. You can also see finished roofs in our metal shingle gallery.
Frequently asked questions
Can I buy replacement metal shingles for an old roof?
Yes. We make diamond metal shingles to order, sized to match the shingles already on the building.
Can you match stamped or embossed metal shingles?
We match the diamond shape and size. Our shingles are smooth, so pressed ornament is not reproduced.
Will new shingles look different from the old ones?
At first, yes. A color match brings them close, and weather narrows the gap over time.
Do I have to replace the whole roof?
Not always. Local damage can often be repaired with matching shingles. A roof that is worn out everywhere is better replaced in the original pattern.